IDPBlitz.com
Individual defensive players
IDP
fantasy defense
fantasy football
Home | Subscribe Now | Tell a Friend | Text Size | Forum: IDP Lineups | Search | Member Area
 About IDPBlitz
 Subscribe Now
 Free Samples
 Origins of IDPBlitz
 Contact Us
 IDP Orientation
 Why Play IDP?
 IDP Strategies
 Setting up an IDP League
 The Mark
 Standard Scoring Systems
 For Everyone
 News and Notes
 IDPBlitz Hall of Fame
 Premium Member Content
 Draft Kit Plus PLATINUM
 IDP Profiles
 IDP Draft Kit
 IDP Rookie Rankings
 IDP Special Reports
 Forum: User columns
 Forum: IDP Draft
 Forum: IDP Keepers
 Forum: IDP Trades
 Forum: Other IDP Topics
 Forum: Feedback IDPBlitz
 IDP Links
Includes non-IDP partner links
Draftsharks - Bold predictions, and IDPBlitz helps with the IDP content.



Monster Draft - Looking for offensive rankings? MonsterDraft customizes all of its rankings based on your league's scoring system. They're worth a look.
Draftcandy - Not IDP, but an amazing drafting system.
Fantasy Football Starters.
 Other
 Our Policy
 Privacy Policy
 Terms of Use


This site powered by MemberGate
home | Free Samples | Upon Further Review - Michael Straha . . .
 





Upon Further Review - Michael Strahan
Cecil Taylor

Go directly to Landon's rebuttal.

OK, I realize this is a minority opinion. Maybe it's even a minority opinion in my own head, since I've consistently ranked Michael Strahan in the Top 10 in the 2006 IDP Draft Kit. But I think there's a nagging possibility of sharp decline in 2006 by this inaugural IDPBlitz Hall of Famer.

I was reminded of this while looking at the list of players who didn't make the dreaded Sept. 2 cut. The Dallas Cowboys released OT Rob Pettiti. Rob Pettiti - Michael Strahan's personal rag doll in 2005. In 2 games, Strahan abused the rookie for a total of 4 sacks. He also collected a sack off rookie Rams OT Alex Barron, for a total of 5 sacks against 1st-year players. Nice work if you can get it.

Now, a great DE is supposed to do this. That is one of many qualities that separates Strahan from, say, Jacksonville's Reggie Hayward, who only mustered 1 sack in 4 games against the turnstile offensive lines in Houston, St. Louis and San Francisco.

But look again at Strahan's recent history. In 2004, he missed half the season with a torn pectoral muscle. Strahan came back 20 pounds lighter and scored 11.5 sacks in '05 - sounds pretty good. But remember, 5 of those 11.5 sacks came at the expense of rookies. In the other 13 games, Strahan only collected 6.5 sacks. Project that over a 16-game season, and the Giants legend wouldn't be so legendary, with a mere 8 sacks. Talk about people starting to call you old. If Strahan had only posted 8 sacks in 2005, the New York media would've been ready to put him out to pasture.

So my question is, will it happen this year? Strahan turns 35 in November. Yes, he's a workout maniac; in the Pro Football Preview version of Sports Illustrated, Osi Umenyiora credits Strahan with teaching him how to work out incredibly hard in order to produce incredible results. But Father Time catches us all, starting first with those of us who eat a lot of doughnuts for breakfast. Well, only on weekends, in my case.

Also, what about the Giants' decision to draft DE Mathias Kiwanuka in the 1st round in 2006? They already had a worthy successor lined up in Justin Tuck, a 2nd year player who looked terrific in camp and was effective on special teams a year ago. Why do you need to go 4-deep unless you think it might only be 3-deep? Or that 1 of the 4 needs a lot more rest than he used to - rest that could also lower his sack totals?

Maybe there are a couple of voices inside my head right now, arguing both sides. Landon Reed will soon voice his displeasure with this opinion and side with 1 of my voices. But if Strahan does decline to mortal single-digit sack totals this season, the other voice gets to say, "I told you so."

Landon's rebuttal

Well here we are for round two of Upon Further Review and I have to tell you, my adoring audience, that I am shocked Cecil is back for more after his sound thumping in round one. (See the previous Upon Further Review column regarding defensive backs in case you missed it.)

The discussion this go-around is that gap-toothed behemoth who is apparently so likable that Brett Favre saw fit to take a dive for him so he could hold the single season sack record. (The record was previously held by Mark Gastineau.) He's 6'5", 275 pounds, and has 14 years of playing experience. He's recorded 129.5 total sacks in his career and doesn't look like he's gonna slow down much this year.

Do I really need to use his name with you? Or, are you thinking: You had me at gap-toothed. You had me at gap-toothed...

Michael Strahan is as good a bet to repeat his numbers this season as any of IDPBlitz's other Top 10 defensive lineman. For some bizarre reason I need to explain it all to the boss, the big cheese, the head honcho, the man who we've all put our fantasy football lives in the hands of, Cecil Taylor. I'm going to assume this is some grand test of his like when Yoda sent Luke into the cave in Empire Strikes Back. If it's not a test, then be afraid, very afraid of any further projections Cecil makes this year! (Just joking, we're all about alternate opinions).

Here's the man's resume. I know that like a mutual fund past performance is not an indicator or future returns, but it's hard not to think that way when you look it over. Go ahead and dream of a 25 percent return on your investment in The Strahan Blue Chip Fund of New York.

Year G Solo Ast Sacks
1994 15 27 13 4.5
1995 15 49 10 7.5
1996 16 54 9 5
1997 16 49 19 14
1998 16 53 14 15
1999 16 43 15 5.5
2000 16 51 15 9.5
2001 16 62 11 22.5
2002 16 57 14 11
2003 16 60 15 18.5
2004 8 25 10 4
2005 16 61 21 11.5

Michael Strahan is, barring injury, good for yet another solid season. Yes, Strahan is getting older, defensive end older at 34, but that's not enough of a reason to doubt his ability. At 34, he's gotten savvier than some of the defensive line coordinators in the league. He knows how to play his position, maintain himself throughout a game and a season. He posted 11.5 sacks last season. He tallied sacks in 8 separate games and remained productive in most other games by using his athleticism to collect 5 tackles or more in 6 of the remaining 9 when he didn't get to the quarterback. That was at age 33, which oh-by-the-way, is also considered a little long in the ole gapped-tooth for a defensive end. One more year, this year, is not going to see his performance collapse suddenly. But, just for giggles, let's say he is going to be noticeably slower this season and more prone to fatigue. On another team, I might worry.

The New York Giants are knowledgeable enough to realize that in two or three years Strahan's productivity will decline. They drafted Justin Tuck and Mathias Kiwanuka the past two seasons to prepare for this eventuality. They did not, however, draft them to fill an immediate need like the Houston Texans did with Mario Williams. By drafting two young, quality defensive ends, the Giants are giving Strahan an even greater likelihood of repeating last season's numbers. Strahan will rest more during games; and while this sort of reduction in playing time usually worries me, instances such as this one I find completely tolerable. Strahan's energy levels will remain high throughout the season because he's getting spelled for a bit.

I can see Cecil is a little wobbly on his feet. His arms are riding low and his feet look like they've cemented themselves to the mat. I may as well give you folks a little more show for your cash before I finish him off with one last blast.

Michael Strahan is going to continue to record sound game play totals because he won't be working alone. Osi Umenyiora is going to draw all the attention this season on the field. He's going to be double teamed, chipped, and held constantly each Sunday afternoon. Umenyiora's trials will be to Strahan's benefit as he'll be matched one-on-one most plays he's in with only a lowly back to try and chip him. Shoot, it'll just tick him off. With Antonio Pierce dropping back to cover short passing lanes and LaVar Arrington darting into the line seeking sacks of his own, Strahan might well be wondering if he hasn't suddenly stepped back into 2001. Too bad they don't play Brett and his boys this year.

Well, I've made the best show of this as I could given what was before me. It's time Ramblin' Landon laid out the final blow. The New York Giants are going to play some classic games this season in Philly, Washington, and Dallas to be sure. They are going to play some lame games too, at least in the trenches, when they play Buffalo, Tennessee, Houston, Tampa Bay, and New Orleans. Those five teams are among the worst offensive lines in the game; and Chicago, Dallas, and Indianapolis only rate middle of the pack. Bad offensive lines will make anyone look like a Pro Bowl player. They'll make Strahan look like a heavy weight champion. POW!

10...9...8...7...6...

-He's not moving folks!

5...4...3...

-The ringside doctor is attending him now!

2...1...

-Time to clean up the mat.